schitt’s creek creator new comedy arrives with Dan Levy back in the spotlight as Big Mistakes puts him at the center of a fast-moving, dysfunctional family crime story. The series casts Levy as Nicky, a nervy pastor hiding his boyfriend from both family and flock, while a stolen necklace pulls him into trouble. Set up as a cringe comedy with a gangland edge, the show leans on escalating chaos, a strong supporting cast, and a blindsiding final twist.
Dan Levy’s latest turn pushes schitt’s creek creator new comedy into darker territory
Levy’s new project follows the breakout success that made Schitt’s Creek a global hit after it first debuted in 2015 on CBC and later found a wider audience on Netflix. This time, the tone is different: Big Mistakes is built around a pastor who is trying to keep a personal secret under wraps while his family life turns increasingly unstable.
The setup is immediate and messy. Nicky’s sister Morgan, played by Taylor Ortega, is described as the hilarious sibling in the mix, while Laurie Metcalf plays a highly strung mother who makes guilt-heavy demands on him. In the first episode, one such demand involves finding a fake diamond necklace for his dying nonna, and that errand quickly spirals into a criminal chase.
What starts as a gift-shop errand turns out to be much bigger than anyone expects. The necklace is real, Morgan steals it, and the pair are hunted by the criminal gang that was meant to be guarding it. The result is a premise that moves quickly, even if some of the plotting stretches credibility.
A sharp cast drives the chaos
The strongest immediate reaction inside the series comes from the performances. Taylor Ortega stands out as Morgan, and Laurie Metcalf brings force to the role of the mother constantly pressing Nicky to do more. Levy, meanwhile, plays Nicky as anxious and cornered, which keeps the comedy rooted in embarrassment and pressure rather than broad gags.
The series is co-created with Rachel Sennott, though she does not appear on screen. That creative pairing helps frame Big Mistakes as a show built around family friction, secrecy, and the discomfort of ordinary people stumbling into dangerous situations.
What the story does and does not explain
The review makes clear that some of the plot mechanics are not fully convincing. The value of the necklace and why it is left in public view are not properly explained, and several developments exist mainly to keep Nicky and Morgan moving through the criminal underworld they have entered.
Even so, the show has momentum. The criminal gang is presented less as terrifying than tiresome, but the final twist changes the shape of the story and sets up a second season. That ending is designed to land as a jolt, even if its impact does not fully last.
Why this matters now
Schitt’s Creek creator new comedy is clearly trying to extend Levy’s reputation beyond the family warmth that defined his earlier hit. Instead of cozy dysfunction, Big Mistakes aims for cringe, secrecy, and crime, with a family at the center of the mess.
For now, the draw is the combination of Levy, Ortega, and Metcalf, plus the promise of a story that keeps shifting under its own feet. If the twist is any indication, Schitt’s Creek creator new comedy is being positioned as a launch point rather than a finished destination, and the next step will depend on whether the show can turn its chaos into something more durable.
